LSU added RJ Luis Jr. to its men's basketball roster on Tuesday. Luis, 23, was the Big East Player of the Year at St. John's in 2025. He then signed a two-way contract with the Utah Jazz. He played three preseason games for the Boston Celtics but never a regular-season NBA game. The SEC later passed a rule barring former pros from returning to its teams. On Friday, Baton Rouge Judge William Jorden ruled that the SEC and NCAA can't penalize LSU for adding him. On Monday, the SEC said in writing it would obey the order. After LSU acted Tuesday, the SEC called it "a deeply concerning and disappointing development."

Luis Won in Court and Should Get to Play

His lawyers and LSU say the courts settled this, and Luis committed to LSU before the SEC changed its rules.

LSU says the court order came first. "RJ secured his eligibility through a court order before the new SEC policy interpretation was announced," LSU President Wade Rousse said. He said LSU is "committed to compliance with NCAA and SEC rules" but is "equally committed to obeying the orders of Louisiana's courts." Luis committed to LSU in May. The SEC adopted its rule against former pros on Aug. 25.

His lawyers say keeping him out would be unfair. "It would be fundamentally unfair to RJ Luis to not allow him to play college ball when you have so many similarly situated young men who are playing in college now," Luis's lawyer Tony Clayton told the Associated Press. Clayton says the Baton Rouge district court, the appeals court and the Louisiana Supreme Court "all ruled in favor of RJ Luis." "RJ is healthy, ready and looking forward to joining his teammates," said Elliot Abrams, another of his lawyers.

Louisiana's attorney general wants the SEC's lawsuit thrown out. Attorney General Liz Murrill filed a motion on LSU's behalf to dismiss the SEC's federal suit. "Enough is enough," she wrote. She called the SEC's claims about Luis a "Hail Mary" that was "demonstrably false."

The SEC Says LSU Is Defying Rules Its Own Members Wrote

The conference says it will obey the court but not let one school decide the rules for everyone else.

The SEC says LSU read the court order its own way. The conference said LSU's decision "to rely on its own interpretation of the Court's order" is "inconsistent with the expectations and responsibilities of membership in the Southeastern Conference." "The Conference will continue to uphold and defend the standards and policies established by its member universities," it said.

SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey says former pros have an unfair edge. "Permitting former professional athletes to return to competition creates a competitive disadvantage and fundamental unfairness for current student-athletes who have not pursued a professional sports career," Sankey has said. In an August letter to a Louisiana judge, he said adding Luis "fuels disruption." He called blocking it "essential to the integrity of college sports." In September, the SEC gave Sankey power to suspend coaches and fine schools up to half of a sport's budget.

The SEC hasn't dropped its lawsuit. The SEC sued LSU in federal court in Alabama. It sued after LSU football coach Lane Kiffin pursued two players who had signed NFL contracts. In an October filing, the SEC said LSU "openly recruited" Luis. It accused LSU of "ongoing defiance of the conference's professionalism rules." A league source told CBS Sports the SEC is following the order. The source said the SEC won't give up its fight over Luis or similar cases.

A Rival Coach Says Former Pros Don't Belong in College Basketball

Florida's coach says college basketball should be for players roughly 19 to 24, not former pros.

Florida coach Todd Golden says this isn't what college basketball is for. "25 and 26-year-olds is not what college basketball is meant to be," Golden said on the podcast The Field of 68 in May. He criticized LSU coach Will Wade for recruiting former pros, including Luis. He said he favors a window of ages 19 to 24.

He says former pros hurt high school recruits. Golden said signing former pros would hurt high school seniors trying to get into college basketball. "We have to have a better solution prior to the season," he said.

Where This Lands

LSU and Luis's lawyers say a court cleared him before the SEC's rule existed. The SEC says LSU is defying rules its members agreed to, and it is still suing. Golden says college basketball isn't meant for former pros. The SEC and LSU are due in federal court in Birmingham, Alabama, on Wednesday morning. That night, No. 25 LSU hosts Louisiana-Monroe at 7 p.m. Central, and Luis could make his debut.

Sources