On Monday, the Supreme Court turned down a Los Angeles eye doctor's challenge to a California rule. California doctors must take 50 hours of continuing education every two years to keep their licenses. Under a 2019 state law, nearly all of those courses have had to cover implicit bias since 2022. Implicit bias means unconscious prejudice. Instructors can give examples of how bias shapes doctors' decisions, or teach ways to address it. Dr. Azadeh Khatibi teaches courses on topics like glaucoma. She sued with the nonprofit Do No Harm. Lower courts threw out the case. They said the courses count as the state's own speech, and the First Amendment doesn't limit what the state itself says. Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch wanted to hear it. That left them one vote short of the four the Court needs. Monday's order doesn't settle whether the rule is constitutional.

The State Can't Make Private Teachers Carry Its Message

This camp says California is forcing doctors to teach its views. Calling it government speech doesn't change that.

A state can't claim a doctor's class as its own speech. Thomas wrote the dissent, and Alito joined it. Gorsuch voted to hear the case but didn't sign on. Thomas noted that private groups often run these courses and private instructors teach them. "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny," he wrote.

This logic could reach far more divisive topics. Thomas asked whether California could make an instructor deliver the state's message on abortion access. He also asked whether it could make instructors teach that gender-transition surgery is ethically required for some patients.

The rule assumes doctors are biased without knowing it. Caleb Trotter is a senior attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents Khatibi for free. He said the rule "tells doctors that their colleagues harbor hidden racial prejudices that no amount of training can fully cure." Do No Harm said medical professionals shouldn't be "compelled by the government to participate in evidence-free implicit bias trainings." Trotter said his side is "encouraged that there is support on the Court" to take up the issue.

But California Decides What Licensed Doctors Must Learn

This camp says the state has always set what doctors study, and instructors who disagree can still say so.

The state has regulated medicine since the 1870s. Judge Jacqueline Nguyen of the federal appeals court opened last year's ruling with that history. The state passed its Medical Practice Act in 1876, after a wave of "quackery" that followed the Gold Rush. Nguyen said implicit bias is like geriatric care, a topic "mandated by the state in its regulatory capacity." She also wrote that Khatibi "is free to teach whatever she wishes" in her own capacity. Last year, UC Berkeley law dean Erwin Chemerinsky called the appeals ruling "clearly correct."

Nobody has to say implicit bias is real. California's lawyers told the Court that "instructors who do not believe that implicit bias exists are free to say so." Those instructors can meet the rule by teaching how to address bias, assuming it exists. The state's brief said doctors "frequently recommend precautions in the face of uncertain scientific evidence."

Lawmakers said the rule would close gaps in care. In 2019, legislators found that Black patients often get less pain medication than white patients with similar problems. They also found that women are less likely to survive a heart attack when a male doctor treats them. Sydney Kamlager-Dove wrote the bill as a state lawmaker. She's now a Democratic congresswoman from California. She has said consistent training for every provider can help close those gaps.

Either Way, Many Bias Trainings Don't Work

This camp says the evidence on these courses is mixed, and the teaching makes the difference.

Lowering someone's bias-test score doesn't seem to change how they act. In 2019, two psychologists reviewed 492 studies of implicit bias, with more than 87,000 participants. They were Calvin Lai of Washington University in St. Louis and Patrick Forscher of the University of Arkansas. They found that people's bias scores can move a little. Sixty-three of the studies also tracked behavior. In those, they found no evidence that changing those scores changed how people acted. "We definitely didn't expect this," Lai said.

Even supporters of the mandates say many trainings don't work. In a 2022 essay in JAMA Health Forum, three researchers backed required bias training for health workers as "1 step forward." They also warned that many bias interventions "have no effect or may even worsen implicit biases."

Experts can make the training work if they teach it right. Dr. Cristina Gonzalez is an internist at NYU Grossman School of Medicine who designs and tests these trainings. She says that when experts deliver them correctly, the trainings work. She thinks California's approach is misguided because it makes every instructor teach the topic, whatever their expertise.

Where This Lands

Two justices say California is forcing private doctors to deliver the state's message. A third wanted to hear the case. Khatibi's lawyers say they'll keep fighting. California says it has always decided what doctors must study. It says instructors who doubt implicit bias can say so in class. Researchers who study the training disagree on whether these courses help. A large 2019 review found no evidence that shifting bias scores changes behavior. For now, nearly every California continuing-education course for doctors still has to cover implicit bias.

Sources