Rod Stewart, 81, canceled his Friday show at San Diego's North Island Credit Union Amphitheatre about 40 minutes before showtime, citing an acute upper respiratory infection and laryngitis on doctor's orders. He said he was "devastated." It was his third recent cancellation — he'd postponed two Las Vegas residency dates weeks earlier with a sinus infection. Then he posted a video from a private jet flying to watch Scotland play Haiti at the World Cup, and was photographed drinking at the match. Ticketholders were sent refund emails.

1. Fans Got Stiffed 40 Minutes Before Curtain (ticketholders)

People were already in their seats. Then he flew to a football match and raised a glass.

Forty minutes' notice is the whole problem. Fans had traveled, parked, and sat down before the San Diego show was scrapped. Refund emails went out, but a refund doesn't give back the night or the gas money.

The World Cup trip is what turned frustration into anger. Right after canceling, Stewart posted a jet video flying to watch Scotland play Haiti — "No Scotland, no party!" — and got photographed drinking at the match. To ticketholders, a man too sick to sing looked plenty well enough to travel and party.

2. He's 81 and Lost His Voice (Rod Stewart)

Laryngitis means a singer has nothing to perform with.

A singer with laryngitis can't do the job. Stewart canceled on doctor's orders with an acute upper respiratory infection that took his voice, and said he was "devastated." For a vocalist, no voice means no show.

This has been a rough stretch, not a one-off. It was his third recent disruption, after he postponed two Las Vegas dates weeks earlier with a sinus infection. At 81, stacking up respiratory infections is its own warning sign.

3. Sick and Tone-Deaf Aren't Opposites (the backlash)

He may really have been ill — and still handled it terribly.

You can lose your singing voice and still be fine to fly. Laryngitis can end a concert while leaving you well enough to get on a plane and watch football. So fans aren't really arguing about whether he was sick.

Canceling, then flying off to drink, is what stung. Posting a jet video and getting photographed with a drink at the World Cup — the same night he scrapped a paid show minutes before showtime — is about as bad as the optics get. He could be genuinely ill and still have handled it terribly.

Where This Lands

Ticketholders say 40 minutes' notice and a refund don't make up for a night they'd already shown up for, especially with the World Cup video right after. Stewart says he's 81, lost his voice to an infection, and had nothing to sing with. And the people in the middle say both things can be true — he was probably sick, and he still picked about the worst possible way to spend the night he canceled on his fans.

Sources