Google has turned down the UK government's request to remove a YouTube video in which comedian Russell Brand says he's innocent, government sources told the BBC. On Sunday, his wife, Laura Brand, read a message from him on the couple's channel. "I am not guilty of the offences I have been jailed for," it said. A jury convicted Brand of one rape and three sexual assaults on Nov. 5, and he's serving 10 and a half years. The Ministry of Justice sent Google a formal request to take the video down. The same sources said Google found the video didn't break its rules. Google itself says only that its teams are "investigating." The Telegraph reports YouTube hasn't decided yet. By Thursday morning the video had more than 850,000 views. The government can't legally force Google to remove it. Meta has already disabled Brand's Instagram and Facebook accounts.
1. YouTube Should Take It Down Now
Prime Minister Andy Burnham's office and his ministers say Brand's victims have heard enough from him.
His victims deserve some peace. A spokesperson for Prime Minister Andy Burnham said Brand's victims "deserve peace" and that "we've heard enough from him." Downing Street called the message "clearly appalling." It also pointed out that prisoners are "strictly banned from making statements that cause distress to victims." Justice Secretary Alex Norris said officials are urgently investigating whether Brand broke prison rules. He could face a temporary phone ban or live monitoring of his calls.
Google should do what Meta did. Children's minister Josh MacAlister said YouTube should follow Meta's lead. "Google should take this down," he said. Housing minister Matthew Pennycook called the video "abhorrent." "We think it is right it comes down," he said.
The video hurts women who've spoken up. Mia Latter, 37, has publicly accused Brand of raping her when she was 16. She wasn't part of the criminal case, and Brand denies her claims. She called his message "upsetting." "I just felt for those women that stood trial and everything they went through," she said.
2. If Google Won't Act, Parliament Should Make It
Former safeguarding minister Jess Phillips says the law needs to go further.
The UK needs a second online safety law. Jess Phillips, a former Home Office safeguarding minister, called for a second Online Safety Act. She noted that right now the government has no power to make YouTube remove the video. She also warned Google. "If Google want less regulation, they should take this down," she said.
3. Ministers Shouldn't Pressure YouTube Unless a Law Was Broken
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and a free-speech outlet say the government shouldn't just demand a takedown.
Brand is guilty, but YouTube is a private company. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said on BBC Radio 4's Today program that Brand "is guilty under the law." She said she's "very concerned" if people in prison can use "other conduits" to send messages. "But YouTube is a private platform," she said. She said demanding a takedown "without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from." She said she's "quite worried about Government intervening."
A free country lets him talk. Dissenter News, a free-speech outlet, called Google's refusal a rare win. It said the government went around the courts with "just a demand and a shame campaign when it's refused." "The proper response from a free society is: let him talk, and let the public judge," it wrote.
Where This Lands
Burnham's government says Brand's victims shouldn't have to hear from him, and it wants YouTube to delete the video. Phillips says that if Google won't act, Parliament should pass a law that forces it to. Badenoch says Brand is guilty, but she wouldn't start by demanding a takedown without checking whether a law was broken. Google says its teams are still investigating, and the video is still up. Meanwhile, the Ministry of Justice is checking whether Brand broke prison rules, and the penalties could include a temporary phone ban.
Sources
- BBC (via Occasional Digest): https://occasionaldigest.com/google-declines-uk-request-for-russell-brand-youtube-video-to-be-removed-sources-say/
- The Telegraph (via Yahoo): https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/burnham-tells-youtube-delete-brand-162155287.html
- ITV News (via Yahoo UK): https://uk.news.yahoo.com/google-thing-over-russell-brand-134321378.html
- Herald Scotland (via Yahoo UK): https://uk.news.yahoo.com/google-refuses-government-request-remove-182600946.html
- AFP (via CP24): https://www.cp24.com/news/entertainment/2026/11/19/uk-asks-youtube-to-remove-russell-brands-innocence-claim-video/
- PA Media (via Gazette): https://www.gazette-news.co.uk/news/national/26745125.google-do-right-thing-russell-brand-video-downing-street-says/
- Yahoo News: https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/article/russell-brands-prison-message-remains-on-youtube-despite-uk-government-calls-for-it-to-be-deleted-150300276.html
- Mandatory (via Yahoo): https://www.yahoo.com/news/world/articles/youtube-refuses-pull-russell-brand-145954771.html
- South London News: https://southlondonnews.co.uk/local/richmond-upon-thames/twickenham/google-russell-brand-video-downing-street/
- Dissenter News: https://dissenter.com/tech/youtube-rejects-uk-censorship-demand-targeting-russell-brand