California's Department of Motor Vehicles has barred Waymo from running or testing driverless cars on any state freeway. The order took effect on Nov. 11 and became public on Tuesday. It follows two incidents this month. On Nov. 5, three Waymos drove into an active construction closure on U.S. 101 near Burlingame. The next day, a Waymo on I-280 in San Francisco tried to get around Highway Patrol cars that were slowing traffic. Officers blocked it with their cruisers. Waymo has now paused freeway rides in all five metro areas where it offered them. Its cars still drive on surface streets. The ban has no end date. It lasts until Waymo proves to the DMV that it has fixed the problem.

Waymo Already Had Its Second Chance

This camp says Waymo already tried to fix this exact problem in the spring, and the fix didn't work.

This is a repeat problem. DMV spokesperson Jonathan Groveman said Waymo's freeway rides "pose an imminent hazard to public safety due to recurring incursions by its vehicles into active construction zones where construction workers, vehicles and equipment are present." He said it happened "despite a prior restriction and corrective actions" that followed similar incidents on May 18.

The spring fix didn't work. In May, seven robotaxis drove into active construction lanes in the Bay Area. Waymo pulled off freeways the next day and recalled 3,871 vehicles in June to address the problem. It started returning to freeways in July. On Nov. 5, three more Waymos rolled into a closure.

At least one rider has lost patience. Elliot Slade is a San Francisco rider whose Waymo went off course into a construction zone earlier this year. "You had one chance to fix it if it went viral," he told ABC7 on Monday. "And if they haven't made sure it's completely safe, then I'm disappointed." He said he used to ride Waymo all the time, but now he'd rather walk or take the bus.

But Nobody Got Hurt, and Robotaxis Are Still Safer

This camp says Waymo is fixing a narrow problem, and one rough patch doesn't erase its safety record.

No one was injured. A Waymo spokesperson said the U.S. 101 encounters "did not involve any injuries or collisions."

Outside California, the company paused on its own. It stopped freeway rides in its other markets "to evaluate our performance." It says it's "working with the California DMV and other state officials diligently and responsibly to resume freeway operations." It will keep testing on freeways with trained specialists behind the wheel.

Every new technology has problems early on. Billy Riggs, a professor at the University of San Francisco, told ABC7, "I see this as an opportunity to continue improving a technology." He said the data still shows self-driving cars are safer than human drivers overall. He also said that many times the cars "can't understand context," even when they read the road well.

Still, the DMV Approved Robotaxis Too Fast

This camp says the state let robotaxis onto its roads before they were ready.

The state rushed robotaxis onto the roads. In August, Teamsters California sued the DMV over its new rules for self-driving trucks. Peter Finn, the union's co-chair, said, "Waymo is just one example of a policy that was rushed and recklessly greenlit by the DMV."

Union leaders warned about this long before now. In January, a robotaxi struck a child near a school. In February, after federal regulators opened an investigation, Finn and fellow co-chair Victor Mineros asked the California Public Utilities Commission to suspend Waymo's license indefinitely. They said policymakers "have repeatedly ignored the growing list of red flags concerning robotaxis."

Where This Lands

The DMV says Waymo's cars kept driving into freeway construction zones even after an earlier restriction and fixes. Waymo says no one was hurt, and it has paused freeway rides everywhere while it reviews its performance. Riggs says the technology is still safer than human drivers. The Teamsters have warned since February that state officials ignored red flags about robotaxis. In August, they said the DMV rushed Waymo's approval. The order has no end date. The ban stays until Waymo shows the DMV it has fixed the problem.

Sources